Readify

Reading “A Jazz Odyssey” at her father’s bedside

Shrill: Notes from a Loud Woman

Reading A Jazz Odyssey at her father’s bedside is a scene from Lindy West’s final visit with her dying father, Paul West Jr. As he drifted in and out of consciousness, West and her sister read from the book he had left unfinished. The episode makes reading aloud both a belated form of closeness and a small, absurdly funny vigil: the sisters follow Oscar Peterson from the open road to a mishap involving a recreational vehicle’s sewage tank, and their father rouses to laugh.

The Last Hospital Visit

The reading took place after the family went to the hospital for the last time. West’s retrospective account sets the scene against her regret over the time she had not spent with her father and the vulnerability she had avoided in their earlier conversations. She had wondered why she had not read aloud to him more, especially the books he had read to her when she was little. At the hospital, as he became less conscious, she and her sister did read to him—an act of care that came after the chances to speak openly had run short.

The hospital room could comfortably hold only two visitors. West, her mother Ingrid, and her sister therefore took turns sleeping in the chair beside the bed and holding her father’s hand, while another family member sat on the cushioned bench beneath the window or went to the cafeteria or family lounge. Within these practical limits, the book offered a shared focus during a vigil organized around waiting and taking turns.

A Book Left Midway Through

The sisters picked up A Jazz Odyssey: The Life of Oscar Peterson, the book Paul West Jr. had been halfway through. Peterson was his hero. West recalls that Ahamefule J. Oluo had described Peterson as a widely respected, genial figure in jazz, and the passage the sisters encountered suited that affectionate portrait: Peterson was travelling around America’s parks and monuments with his wife, Kelly, in a new Winnebago.

The details are domestic rather than glamorous. Peterson admires the vehicle’s chrome accents and spacious over-cab bed, and the journey with Kelly seems to him an ideal life. Then the account turns to emptying the sewage tank. Peterson is confident he can manage it himself. West looks from the book to her sister’s expectant face and to her father, unconscious in the bed, realizing that the story may soon describe the couple’s liquefied waste spraying out of the vehicle. She reads on aloud in a soothing voice. The blunt collision between the bedside setting and the book’s scatological comedy is the scene’s central turn.

Laughter in the Vigil

Before the sewage-tank episode, Paul West Jr. rouses occasionally and chuckles as Peterson describes the Winnebago. His laughter connects him, however briefly, to the story his daughters are reading and to the pleasures that had made the book his choice. The passage does not suggest that he is awake for every detail; West explicitly looks over at his unconscious father before deciding to continue. The reading persists even as his awareness comes and goes.

The scene’s humor does not cancel the gravity of the hospital vigil. In the surrounding account, West describes the point at which doctors could no longer feasibly address her father’s internal bleeding and dehydration, and the family had to accept medication to ease his suffering. Against that knowledge, the sisters’ reading is neither a cure nor a denial of what is happening. It is a concrete act of presence, made out of the book at hand—and, unexpectedly, a story about a Winnebago sewage tank.

Related StoryFlow